First Page No.
1
Last Page No.
29
Abstract
In nine separate lawsuits against public universities since 2018, a nonprofit advocacy group called Speech First, Inc. has mitigated the efforts of higher education administrators to balance speech and antidiscrimination interests in support of traditionally marginalized students who experience racist, misogynistic, or otherwise bigoted speech in the classroom or on campus. Under longstanding approaches to First Amendment rights to free expression that champion unrestricted exchange in the marketplace of ideas above all else, Speech First’s challenges have been successful. This Note explores the now-vacated Fourth Circuit opinion in Speech First v. Sands, which joined a minority in an emerging circuit split to uphold bias response policies at Virginia Tech on the grounds that the policies are a form of government speech and do not offend the First Amendment. Connecting the opinion to literature from critical race theory and legal realism that advocates for balancing between free expression and antidiscrimination principles in higher education, this Note considers the potential benefits of a more nuanced approach to the marketplace of ideas on college campuses, as well as the state of play at public colleges and universities in the aftermath of the Supreme Court’s decision to vacate Sands.