A Mixed Methods Examination of Structural Bigenderism and the Consequences for Transgender and Gender Variant People
Date of Award
Nelson E. Walls, Ph.D.
Higher education, Mixed methods, Social welfare settings, Social work, Structural bigenderism, Transgender
For years, transgender activists and their allies have spoken out about the oppression that transgender and gender non-conforming people experience in relation to societal systems and institutions, due to policies and practices that do not acknowledge non-binary experiences of gender, that do not recognize that one's gender may change over time or may not match cultural expectations for gender expression, and that punish and discriminate against trans people (Gilbert, 2009; Lombardi & Davis, 2006; Markman, 2011; Spade, 2006; WWRC, 2010). Scholars have called for human services professionals and researchers to critique the failures of institutions in society (and the people within them) that continue to reproduce oppressive patterns related to gender (Davis, 2008; Markman, 2011; Spade, 2006; Wilchins, 2004). This dissertation examines the topic of structural bigenderism, using a mixed methods analysis of data based on the lives of transgender and gender non-conforming people in two settings of interest to social workers--social welfare settings and higher education.
This study analyzes secondary data from two community-based projects: a qualitative participatory research project in Colorado of 30 transgender people's experiences in higher education, and a national survey conducted by the National Center for Transgender Equality and the National Gay and Lesbian Task Force of transgender people's experiences of discrimination across a variety of settings (Grant et al., 2011). Qualitative themes provide detail about problematic institutional practices, interactions with people who embody the power of the institution, and suggestions for improving higher education settings. Quantitative findings (with sample sizes ranging from n = 296 to n = 3,480, depending on the model) indicate a general pattern that transgender people who held multiple marginalized identities were at greatest risk of unequal treatment in social welfare settings, being denied access to or thrown out of homeless shelters, being denied financial aid or scholarships, being denied access to gender-appropriate spaces at school, and being prohibited from changing their student records to reflect their gender. Joint data displays explore the role of intersectionality in transgender people's experiences in higher education. The study concludes with a discussion of implications for social work practitioners and educators.
Copyright is held by the author. User is responsible for all copyright compliance.
Seelman, Kristie Lynn, "A Mixed Methods Examination of Structural Bigenderism and the Consequences for Transgender and Gender Variant People" (2013). Electronic Theses and Dissertations. 587.
Received from ProQuest
Kristie Lynn Seelman
Social work, Higher education, Social structure