Errors in Converting Principles to Protocols: Where the Bioethics of US Covid‐19 Vaccine Allocation Went Wrong

Authors

William F. Parker, University of Chicago
Govind C. Persad, University of DenverFollow
Monica E. Peek, University of Chicago

Publication Date

2022

Document Type

Article

Organizational Units

Sturm College of Law

Keywords

COVID, Vaccines, Bioethics, CDC, Immunization

Abstract

For much of 2021, allocating the scarce supply of Covid-19 vaccines was the world's most pressing bioethical challenge, and similar challenges may recur for novel therapies and future vaccines. In the United States, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention's Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP) identified three fundamental ethical principles to guide the process: maximize benefits, promote justice, and mitigate health inequities. We argue that critical components of the recommended protocol were internally inconsistent with these principles. Specifically, the ACIP violated its principles by recommending overly broad health care worker priority in phase 1a, using being at least seventy-five years of age as the only criterion to identify individuals at high risk of death from Covid-19 during phase 1b, failing to recommend place-based vaccine distribution, and implicitly endorsing first-come, first-served allocation. More rigorous empirical work and the development of a complete ethical framework that recognizes trade-offs between principles may have prevented these mistakes and saved lives.

Copyright Date

2022

Copyright Statement / License for Reuse

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

Publication Statement

User is responsible for all copyright compliance. This article was originally published as William F. Parker, Govind Persad & Monica E. Peek, Errors in Converting Principles to Protocols: Where the Bioethics of US Covid‐19 Vaccine Allocation Went Wrong, 52 Hastings Ctr. Rep. 8 (2022).

File Format

application/pdf

Recommended Citation

William F. Parker, Govind Persad & Monica E. Peek, Errors in Converting Principles to Protocols: Where the Bioethics of US Covid‐19 Vaccine Allocation Went Wrong, 52 Hastings Ctr. Rep. 8 (2022).